How do you compare proxy providers?
To compare proxy providers, give both the same job at the same time and see which one opens more pages, works faster and costs less per page that worked. Caiman Check does this for you: paste proxies from two providers and get a report in a few minutes.
What does “the same job” mean?
For a fair comparison of proxy providers, “the same job” means the same websites, the same country, the same type of proxy and the same moment.
Compare residential proxies with residential, rotating with rotating. If one provider gets easier sites or a different country, you compare the conditions, not the providers.
Why test both providers at the same time?
Test both proxy providers at the same time because proxies change during the day: testing one today and the other tomorrow is like timing two runners on different days.
Residential proxies are real home connections. Which homes are online changes by the hour, so the same provider can look better in the morning than at night.
What counts as a successful request?
A request through a proxy is successful when the page opened and showed what you need. A captcha or an “access denied” page is a failure, even if the server says “OK”.
Sites often send a block page with the normal “200 OK” status, so look at the page itself. Write down why the other requests failed: blocked, too slow, could not connect, wrong country. The reasons show what to fix.
How do I measure proxy speed?
Measure proxy speed by the typical time, not the average, because one very slow request can spoil the average.
The typical time (the median) is the middle value: half of the requests were faster, half were slower. Also look at the slowest requests: they are what makes your jobs wait.
How do I know which provider is cheaper?
The cheaper proxy provider is the one that costs less per page that worked, not per gigabyte, because failed requests use paid traffic too.
| Price per GB | Traffic used | Pages that worked | Per 1,000 pages | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Provider A | $4 | 1.5 GB | 800 | $7.50 |
| Provider B | $3 | 2.0 GB | 600 | $10.00 |
B's gigabyte is a quarter cheaper, but each page that worked costs a third more.
How to count: what you paid for the test ÷ pages that worked × 1,000.
How many requests do I need?
To compare proxy providers fairly, you need at least a few hundred requests for each provider: with fewer, luck decides the result.
With 100 requests the result can easily be off by 5–10 percent either way. Before a big purchase, run the test again at a different time of day.
How do I know the difference is real and not luck?
A small gap between two proxy providers, a few percent, is usually luck; it is real only if a statistical test says so.
Statisticians check this with tests such as Fisher's exact test. Caiman Check runs this check for every number and names a winner only when the difference is real; otherwise it says the providers are about equal. A price gap under 15% counts as a tie: providers count traffic slightly differently. Details: how we test.
What else should I check for my task?
What else to check depends on your task: for antidetect browsers, where the proxy IP is and whether it looks like a home user; for scraping, success and price on your own sites; for a bought list, how many lines actually work.
- Antidetect and multi-accounting: country and city of the IP, a home internet provider or a server (hosting, datacenter), which system the site sees, and whether UDP works (needed for WebRTC).
- Scraping: how many pages open on the sites you need, the price per page, and how the provider handles many requests at once.
- A list of static or sticky proxies: which lines work and which are dead, so you can ask the provider to replace them.
Caiman Check shows all of this in one report.
What mistakes should I avoid?
The most common mistakes when comparing proxy providers are different settings for each provider, too few requests, and testing only on “what is my IP” sites, which never block anyone.
- Different proxy types or countries for each provider.
- Conclusions from 20–50 requests.
- Testing only on sites that show your IP: every provider looks equally good there.
- Trusting the traffic counter in the provider's dashboard without checking.
Is there a tool that compares proxy providers automatically?
Yes. Caiman Check sends the same requests through two proxy providers at the same time and tells you which one is better and whether the difference is real.
Paste proxy lines from both providers; the report is ready in a few minutes. It works with residential and mobile proxies. Full methodology: how we test.